October 3, 2011

The Mighty Archetype: Broody Jerks with Hearts of Gold

No, the 'Broody Jerks with Hearts of Gold' isn't an official archetype name :)

In manga, I have always been drawn to the same sort of character--dark, broody, jerks who hide their high morals and tragic pasts behind a bad attitude and fortified emotional walls. A lot of times, they also have fabulous hair and carry a sword.

Exhibit A: Sasuke Uchiha from Naruto

*Official art from the creator Masashi Kishimoto*

        Sasuke, whose entire clan was murdered when he was a child by his older brother, and has spent every minute of every day since training for the day when he'd be strong enough to face his brother and avenge their clan. He's antisocial, speaks his mind, has a superiority complex and is quick to insult others. But he's also just as quick to risk his life in order to protect his teammates, and he did nearly die to protect Naruto, the title character.
        At the moment, he's in the middle of a huge character arc in which he has become Naruto's enemy. But I have complete confidence that, by the end of the series, Sasuke will find the right path and redeem himself.


Exhibit B: Yuu Kanda from D.Gray-man


*Official art from the creator Katsura Hoshino*

        He's the result of an experiment, with little memory of his previous life aside from the vision of a woman he has devoted himself to finding again. He's technically a failed experiment and he was almost disposed of, but his first and only friend (a fellow experimentee) saved him. That same friend later went mad and Kanda was forced to kill him. Despite his bitterness, he still fights to protect people from the akuma (demons) and remains loyal to the Black Order, the same religious organization that created him.

What draws me to this archetype is that s/he is so intensely layered. Sasuke and Kanda have both buried their pain beneath these rude, arrogant exteriors that shatter in the face of their pasts. And with such difficult pasts, it would have been easy for them to have grown distorted and corrupt as they pursued their goals, but they didn't. They clung to their morals, to the good in them, and it's the one defining thing that sets them apart from the antagonists.

How do you guys feel about this archetype? And what's YOUR favorite archetype?

Who are some literary characters you can think of that fit this archetype?

Naturally, I've drawn my two favorite swordsmen:


Have a great week! ♥

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Gahhhh your art is so pretty! The line densities...they make me happy.

Sasuke is still definitely my favorite character. But I think one of my favorite (manga/anime, at least) archetypes is the goofy guy who is actually a badass. (For example, Urahara from Bleach.) Because you NEVER EXPECT IT.
2 replies · active 703 weeks ago
Also, Madara from Naruto who was the weird goofy guy with the mask in the beginning. LOL :O
Thank you! And yes, I agree with you! That will have to be another archetype to discuss XD
Yeah, I'm totally drawn to this kind of archetype too, but it's not just any kind of jerkish behavior that'll do for me. I get hooked by the cold, imperious types. Prettiness helps too. :P

I would also add that I like shady characters too because you can't ever tell what they're up to or even whose side they're really on. I guess I like being kept on my toes. Haha.
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
Haha, omg yes. Cold and imperious is a perfect way to describe both Sasuke and Kanda. And the prettiness, obvsly *cough* :D

Ambiguous morals are attractive, especially if he chooses to do the right thing in the end. And in Sasuke's case, apparently even when he doesn't lol.
Oh yeah! I love a bad boy with a secret heart of gold. These are the most satisfying heroes to me :)
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
It's so fun to see their layers get peeled away when they're faced with difficult choices and situations *_*
Alleged Author's avatar

Alleged Author · 703 weeks ago

I think I have a thing for broody jerks as well. There's something so mysterious about them. Mmmm.
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
Yes XD Only in fiction though. I don't think I'd be able to handle them in real life =P
I started reading and then BAM... SASUKE. *brain pffffffts*

I fLOVE this archetype...I think Sasuke's brother, Itachi, also falls into this category. *insert swoon here*

Your 'broody jerks with hearts of gold' descript reminds me of another swoon-worthy badboy that I can't seem to stop fantasizing about. *coughs* And he also carries a sword. *dies*brain pfffffts again*
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
OMG ME TOO LMAO

I'm still divided about Itachi. On the one hand, he did everything for Sasuke. On the other hand, he gave Sasuke an epic mindfuck and screwed him up for life. HMMM lol.
Yes, I love this archetype because it takes a while to get to know the character and the more you get to know them the more you're drawn to them.
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
Yes, exactly! Watching them reveal their layers is riveting.
'Broody Jerks with Hearts of Gold' isn't an official archetype name" IT IS TOO! In my book, anyway. Hee.

Oh, Lori. Why'd ya have to go make me fall in love with Sasuke? I mean, an experiment meant to be disposed, then escaped and had to kill the one who saved him?? I just want to hold him until his walls fall down.

Yes, these are my faves, too. And manga showcases them so well. :) Thanks for sharing that! BTW, your Swordsmen are HAWT. Hee
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
Actually, that's Kanda XD But they are very similar! And Kanda's walls have... sort of come down in recent chapters. It's beautiful to see him smile for once anyway :D

Thanks so much, anita! <3
I HATE Jace Weyland.
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
LMAO. I don't hate him, but I'm not in love with him either. (Give me Four from Divergent any day *_*)
I like plot archetypes: Call to action, acceptance of call, at least three try/fail cycles (including a dark night of the soul), climax, resolution. It's amazing how many novels follow this.
1 reply · active 703 weeks ago
Oooh excellent point. Plot archetypes are great too, depending on how interesting a writer can make them. And they obviously work for a reason :D
Ahh,I hate to do this, I don't want to be the dissenter in this topic but I really don't like Sasuke. I find him to be really annoying and I don't think he has a heart of gold at all. Yes, he has a tragic past but he takes it to a whole another level. Or maybe I don't like him cause he makes Sakura into a weak character, constantly pining after. I think I dislike both of them. Oh well.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 

Lori M Lee Copyright © 2010 Design by Ipietoon Blogger Template Graphics from Questofdreams (Lori Lee)