December 5, 2011

The Mighty Archetype: Good Guys Gone Bad

Good Guys Gone Bad - These are the ones who break your heart.

Exhibit A: Phoenix from the Marvel Universe

*Official art*
        When Jean Grey apparently died saving the rest of her team from a shuttle crash, she emerged from the depths of the ocean in X-Men #101 as The Phoenix, an incredibly powerful being.
        She maintains her new power level as a hero for about two years, before the Hellfire Club starts messing with her mind, guiding her toward, for lack of a better term, the dark side. (Source.)


Exhibit B: Chun-Woo Han from The Breaker
*Official art by illustrator Jin-Hwan Park*
        Also known as Goomoonryong, or "Nine Arts Dragon," he had some ambiguous morals, but he always pulled through in the end, including nearly getting himself killed a couple times to protect his pupil. But when the girl he's been pretending not to be in love sacrifices herself for him (and he fails to save her), it pushes him over the edge. He abandons his pupil and sets out for revenge.

So, as you can see, the transformation from good to evil can be a result of both external and internal causes. Maybe the character gets captured and fitted with a device like Sam's watch in Transformers: Dark of the Moon, which forces him to betray his friends and comrades. Or maybe making the "wrong" decision becomes the right one in order to save someone important. Or, like Chun-Woo (and Riku from Kingdom Hearts or Sasuke from Naruto), maybe he's always had a little bit of darkness inside him, and all it took was a compelling push to cross the line.

It hurts most when, like Chun-Woo, the character starts out perfectly likable. He's flawed and kind of shallow, but he's a good person. Readers grow to love him, to see him as their security blanket for how insanely kickass he is and how he always pulls through. So when something happens and the light switches, it's devastating. If you can do that to your readers, you're doing something right :) (and they might hate you for it, but that might be okay too lol)

So what do you guys think? Harvey Dent from The Dark Knight would also be a great example of this archetype! Who else fits?



Previous posts in the archetype series:
1: Broody Jerks with Hearts of Gold
2: The Hero Who Hides Behind a Smile
3: The Goofy Guy Who Secretly Kicks Ass
4: The Designated Psychopath
5: The Mad Scientist
6: The Child Prodigy

Have a great week!

Comments (7)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I actually just did this with my current WIP's character. Something happens that switches her goals from good to pure revenge and she loses sight of everything else. It was a hard thing to pen, but very fun! I hope readers like it! I guess I will find out soon enough, hehe!
I think this one can be particularly hard to do well without falling into stereotypes. Because essentially you are creating two characters here, good and bad, and as we already know the most compelling villains/bad guys are the ones who can be redeemable, so this trajectory from good to bad needs to happen in ways that are justified by the story, believable in terms of the character, and devastating in terms of stakes. A tough order!
I had to stop by and read this when I saw a picture of Dark Phoenix. What a fascinating storyline in comics. Boy was it fun to read when it came out.
This archetype is both awesome and SO frustrating. I have to add Anakin to this list. Think he's ridic/dumb in the movies, but he's actually LIKEABLE in the Clone Wars TV series, which makes it sad that he turns.
Ooh, Harvey Dent is a great example! My heart broke a bit when he turned... These are great reminders for us, because I hate when I accidentally write in a "Snidely Whiplash" villain. Thanks for posting this!
AH Goomoonryong ;_; that one hurts me.

Also Dark Phoenix *_* nice choice, and a classic. I always love that arc!!!
What happened to Chun-woo (and what happened to Shiho!) really broke my heart. I can usually take it when it happens to other characters but how it was executed in Breaker destroyed me.

Post a new comment

Comments by

 

Lori M Lee Copyright © 2010 Design by Ipietoon Blogger Template Graphics from Questofdreams (Lori Lee)