April 9, 2012

Fanfiction was my best teacher

First, some back story (feel free to skip):

I entered college majoring in education. Less than a semester in, I remembered I hated talking in front of people and what the heck was I thinking?! So I did what I should have in the first place and majored in creative writing (and to hell with it not being practical).

To be honest, my writing courses were... okay. I had one professor who was phenomenal. I was fortunate to have her both in my sophomore year and for my senior capstone. She told me all the hard things I needed to hear about my writing. The other classes, however... well. I wasn't terribly impressed, and my writing felt stagnant. At the time, I was also reintroducing myself to anime, and it wasn't long before I discovered fandom and fanfiction.

A year later, I was still feeling discontent about my writing. After reading a particularly well-written fanfic, I decided I wanted to try it myself. I quickly fell in love, and over the span of the next several years, I wrote over 70 pieces of fanfiction, varying in length from 100-word drabbles to full-length 100k+ word novels.

/end back story

The point is that fanfiction renewed my writing muse. There were numerous reasons why, but the biggest reason was this: quality writers.

I know, not what you were expecting, right? And also not the first thing to come to mind when seeing the word 'fanfiction.' In fact, after spending years in fandom, I know that most fanfics aren't that great.


It's true--fandom is filled with drivel. Lots and lots of it. And lots of it. AND LOTS OF IT. But if you keep looking, you will find those writers who leave you squinting through the sheer dazzle of their talent. Who can string words like a dream, whose stories will leave you a blubbering mess or in euphoria (and also questioning why on earth they're not published).

I was fortunate enough to call many of those writers my friends, and they inspired me and taught me more about storytelling than any college class ever did. Every time I felt down about my own writing, I went back into one of their stories and reread a few favorite passages. Almost instantly, I felt renewed all over again.

Through them, I learned what powerful storytelling was. I learned that dramatic moments were strongest delivered with subtlety, that the best stories were layered, and that characterization was everything. I learned that pantsing really didn't work for me, that my favorite relationships were those forged in adversity, rivalry and camaraderie, and that the most important thing about writing any story is to make the reader care.

But even the fanfics that weren't good helped me, because they taught me what not to do--although it took me a while to get there because, just like in any profession, you have to develop an eye for what's good and what's not through time and exposure.

The desire to continue improving within this setting meant I wrote a LOT of fanfiction, and through sheer practice and an evolving understanding of my writing, I got better.

Fanfiction was a VITAL part of my growth as a writer, and my fellow fanficcers were my best teachers.

---

I was going to write a post about why fanfiction is so beneficial to budding writers, and then I saw this in my blog feed and went "MY THOUGHTS EXACTLY!" :)

Gwen on The Benefits of Writing Fanfiction

There's also this amusing and accurate post on fanfiction by Yan at Books By Their Cover:

Rant: FanFiction

Happy Monday, everyone!




Comments (24)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
So much truth, Lori. I'm an aspiring writer myself, although I have never taken any creating writing courses myself (I'm also an aspiring translator, and there's just this much you can do at the same time xD). Fanfiction has been my companion for years now.
And I admit that I learned how to write because of my fanfiction writing friends. Sure, getting good reviews/comments is ego boosting, but it's the constructive critique that kept me rolling! I kind of regret that I stopped writing at some point. ;)

I agree that even bad fanfiction teaches us something - how NOT to write. How many times did we cringe reading something? I did, a lot. And I usually left without commenting, because there are rarely bad (fanfiction and not only) writers that want to see their work criticized. Hm.

Thanks for this post, Lori! :)
Agnieszka @ Nook of Books
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
I agree, especially about writers not wanting their work criticized. And that's completely their right--fanfiction is just for fun after all. The ones that really annoyed me, though, was the authors who said 'please critique my work' in order to sound cool when they really meant 'please praise me.' And then flew off the handle when someone actually did offer crit. Ah, fanfic writers. So many lolz =P
Well, fandom has no gatekeepers like agents/editors so we have to be our own slush reader to find the gems. Although there is a sort of rec system within specific fandoms so that the good stuff gets passed around.

I think the self-pub field is going to look more and more like fandom in that way, with reviewers turning into the gem-finders for everybody else.
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
I love the rec system. I even have a rec list of my own for Naruto fanfiction lol.
Intersting post! It's always cool to see how other writer's develop. I've never read or written fan fic before, but now i"m genuinely curious:D
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
I used to think it was all drivel. I was proven wrong though, and I'm glad XD
Good fanfiction can be amazing, so that's a great place to get your inspiration from. I do think fanfiction can be a great way to hone your skills and I'm so glad you've moved on, so to speak, so that we can now enjoy your original creations :)
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
Me too! XD I'm very happy where I am right now.
I haven't read any fanfiction. Maybe I should. And I always wish I would have taken some creative writing in college. Because I'm so having to learn the hard way through all my mistakes.
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
Fanfiction was definitely worth more than most of my college courses (most b/c, as I said, I had one fabulous prof who knew what she was doing).
Agree with you so much on all of this. Fanfiction can be pretty amazing, and you can and do learn a lot. Some of my favorite published writers now were fanfic writers, and I remember being so in love with their fanfic writing.
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
I love it when published authors admit they were fanfic writers b/c it lends some credibility to learning through fanfic lol.
There's something to be said for drabbles. They often pack a wallop and can teach a lot about being concise.
I was just learning about fan fiction from my friend! I was like "you did what?" But she says it totally helped her writing and got her into it, etc. http://prolificnovelista.com/2012/podcast-your-go... (Great Jurassic Park photo btw)
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
Oh how cool! Sorry i didn't get to it until now, but thanks for linking!
Fan fiction also taught me how to write. : ) It's sadly been a long time since I stopped posting for one story I was writing, and I get an email once every few weeks from a new fan, asking me to finish. Honestly, I think it's been two years since I started that particular fanfiction series, and it's been 8-10 since the show was canceled. There's either some really devoted fans, or my cliff hangers are *that* good.
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
Yes! Fandoms are still going strong for many completed tv series, and I love that! I also have a few unfinished fanfics that I get requests to finish, and I don't quite have the heart to tell them it will probably never happen ^^;
I've never really tried fanfic before, but I can see how it would be a lot of fun. And it gets you writing, which is really the important part. Words on paper, learning how it works best for you, is the best teacher. Great post!
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
Thanks, Meradeth! Absolutely, fanfic is a great way to focus on craft and characterization without worrying too much on world building.
Haha, I wrote a lot of fanfiction and most of it was for Naruto XD (although it was of the SasukexNaruto variety so... lol) You shouldn't feel guilty about writing/reading fanfiction--I think the authors who turn their nose up at it alienate their fans, and that's a pretty foolish move imo.
I never learned much from my creative writing courses, either. Totally can relate to that. I also got into writing fan fic some years ago and it was all I wanted to write for a long time, until I started thinking of original ideas. I'd say it was beneficial for my writing, too, but also caused some problems. I think you don't have to push yourself when you write fan fic, so you let a lot of things slide that you wouldn't otherwise.

Still, I've had to study the craft of writing through books on the craft and just fiction written in my genre, but learning how to write in my voice and being comfortable with it mostly came from writing fan fic.
1 reply · active 673 weeks ago
That's totally true! And I wrote a post about that here: http://lorimlee.blogspot.com/2011/12/deja-vu-blog...

:D

Post a new comment

Comments by

 

Lori M Lee Copyright © 2010 Design by Ipietoon Blogger Template Graphics from Questofdreams (Lori Lee)